Qualitative Sustainability Assessment of the Large- Scale Redevelopment Plan in Samen District of Mashhad

Document Type: Original Paper

Authors

1 Ph.D. Candidate, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Faculty of Art and Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Redevelopment of distressed and blighted areas are targeted by most of development policies.
However, a number of policies have been changed as the result of the ineffectiveness of the previous experiences, the
incompatibility of the development tools and plans, the lack of financial resources or social movements. Large-scale
redevelopment projects have usually been considered as the powerful tools for urban revitalization, modernization
and implementation of radical plans while many of those were criticized due to their various consequences including
social exclusion, inequality, social conflicts, environmental damages, inconsistent scale, etc. Downtown of the City of
Mashhad; Samen District, has experienced various physical interventions in the form of large-scale projects during the
last century. Although the projects and intervention policies have been transformed during the past decades, previous
faults were ignored and sometimes were iterated in these experiences. In fact, it seems that urban development
solutions in the district have not been sustainable solutions and couldn’t maintain or shape a sustainable community
in the historical and formerly economic urban core of Mashhad. This paper, focusing on mega redevelopment
projects experienced in Samen Districst after 1920s, aims to highlight the critical aspects neglected or bent in Samen
redevelopment program. Based on the nature of large-scale redevelopment projects and the current sustainability
criteria, it qualitatively assesses the sustainability of the redevelopment projects through content-analysis method.
According to the results, despite the competitiveness and place promotion goals of the Samen redevelopment project,
the adopted approaches and policies could not lead to a state of sustainable development.

Keywords


Altshuler, A. &Luberoff, D. (2003). Mega-Projects: The Changing Politics of Urban Public Investment, Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, Cambridge, Mass: Washington, D.C. and Brookings Institution Press.

Alinezad, M. A. (2012). The Central Distressed Area in Mashhad, Khorasannews, Retrieved September 2015, from http://www.khorasannews.com/News.aspx?year=1391&month=4&day=25&id=4353280

Akbari Motlagh, M. (2014). Assessing the intervention experiences in Central district of Mashhad (Barresi Tajarobe Modakhele dar Baft Markazi Shahre Mashhad), Pazuheshkade Shahrzazi va Memari Sepidar, Retrieved August 12, 2015, from http://seppidar.ir/mostafa-akbari-motlaq/1106

Ahmadi, M. (2010). Assessing the Appropriate Financing Methods for Redevelopment Plan of Distressed Area Around Razavi Holy Shrine (Barrasi Shivehaye Monaseb Tamin Mali Tarh Behsazi va Nosazi Bafte Farsude Piramun Haram Razavi, Mashhad: Ferdowsi University of Mashhad.

Asgharpour Masule, A. & Behravan, H. (2010). A Conceptual Framework for Sociological Assessment of Cooperation between Actors in Redevelopment of Distressed Area Focusing on Samen District in Mashhad (Charchubi Mafhumi Baraye Tahlile Jameeshenkhti Hamkari Miane Koneshgaran dar Barname Nosazi Bafthaye Farsude ba Takid bar Mantaghe Samen Mashhad), Mashhad Pazuhi (5), 35-56.

Arefi, M & Meyers, W. R. (2003). What is public about public space: The case of Visakhapatnam, India, Cities, 20 (5), 331–339.

Arefi, M. (2004). An Asset-based Approach to Policymaking: Revisiting the History of Urban Planning and Neighborhood Change in Cincinnati’s West End, Cities, 21(6), 491–500. DOI:10.1016/j.cities.2004.08.003.

Bahreyni, S. H., Izadi, M. S. & Modiri, M. (2013). Urban Renewal Approaches and Policies (from Redevelopment to sustainable regeneration) (Ruykardha va Siyasathaye Nosazi Shahri (Az Bazsazi ta Bazafarini Shahri Paydar), Motaleat Shahri (9), 17- 31.

Borbor, D. (n.d.). Renovation of the Surrounding of Imam Reza’s Shrine (np), Retrieved September 15, 2015, from https://dariushborbor.academia.edu/DariushBorborcom

Borbor, D. (1971). An Ancient Concept in Ancient Land, Urban Planning, Keyhan International, Octorber 13th 1971, 6.

Erfanian Salim, M & Asgharzade, A. (2013). Recognition of Sarshur Bazar Placement in Existed City Structure (Bazshenasi Jaygah Bazar Sarshur dar Sakhtare Konuni Shahre Mashhad), Haft Shahr 44-43, 17-29.

Farsnews (2014). Retrieved September 15, 2015, from http://www.farsnews.com/newstext.php?nn=13930818001051.

Flyvbjerg, B. (2007). Mega projects, Policy and Planning, Aslborg: Aslborg Universitet.

Flyvbjerg, B. (2007). Cost Overruns and Demand Shortfalls in Urban Rail and Other Infrastructure, Transportation Planning and Technology, 30(1), 9–30. DOI: 10.1080/03081060701207938.

Flyvbjerg, B. (2012). Why Mass Media Matter to Planning Research: The Case of Megaprojects, Planning and Education research 32(2), 169-181. DOI: 10.1177/0739456X12441950.

Ghalambor Dezfooy, R. (2013). Sustainable Criteria Evaluation of Neighbourhoods Through Residents’ Perceived Needs, International Journal of Architecture and Urban Development 3(2), 39-48.

Hanachi, P. & Fadayinezad, S. (2011). The Formulation of a conceptual Framework for integrated Conservation and Regeneration in Cultural and Historical areas (Tadvin Carchub Mafhumi Hefazat va Bazafarini Yekparche dar Bafthaye Farhangi va Tarikhi), Honarhaye Ziba (46), 15-26.

Hosseyni, S. J. (2008). Constant Public Association in Reconstruction and Development of Urban Distressed Areas, Mashhad : Sokhan Gostar.

IRNA (2014). Retrieved September 15, 2015, from http://www.irna.ir/fa/News/81379857/

IRNA (2015). Retrieved September 15, 2015, from http://www.irna.ir/fa/News/81748280/.

ISNA (2015). Retrieved September 14, 2015, from http://www.isna.ir/fa/news/

Jafarzade Najar, M. & Jannati Namin, M. (2013). The Assessment of Financing method in the distressed area around Imam Reza’s holy shrine (Barrasi Shivehaye Tamin Manabe Mali dar Bafte Farsude Piramun Haram Imam Reza), Haft Shahr 43-44, 53-70.

Jalali, S. (2012). Design Principles of Connection between Urban Texture and Sacred Space of Imam Reza Holy Shrine, unpublished Master’s Thesis, Islamic Azad University Central Tehran Branch, Tehran.

Jamejamonline (2015). Retrieved September 15, 2015, from http://www.jamejamonline.ir/newspreview/1947410869871604349

KianPour, M. (2015). Retrieved September 20, 2015,from http://www.dolat.ir/NSite/FullStory/News/?Serv=0&Id=212787

Kudadirgwa, C. R. (2013). Designing Megaprojects: A Case Study of Community Participation in the Design of High Speed 2, unpublished Master’s Thesis, Faculty of Humanities,   University of Manchester, Manchester, Uk.

Lehrer, U. & Laidley, J. (2009). Old Mega-Projects Newly Packaged? Waterfront Redevelopment in Toronto, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 32 (4), 786-803. DOI:10.1111/j.1468-2427.2008.00830.x.

Lotfi, S. (2011). Culture-led Urban Regeneration (Bazafarini Shahri Farhang Mabna: Taammoli bar Bonmayehaye Farhangi va Konesh Bazafarini), Honarhaye Ziba (45), 47-60.

Mariotte, S. (2007). Large-Scale Urban Development Projects in Europe, Drivers of Change in City Regions, Paris: IAURIF.

Mashhad Municipality. (2015). Retrieved February 10, 2015, from www.news.mashhad.ir.

Mihanblog. (2015). Retrieved February 23, 2015, from http://www.meshad.mihanblog.com.

Moztarzadeh, H., Mofidi Shemirani, S. M. & Hodjati, V. (2013). Explaining the Components of Sustainability in Urban Communities, International Journal of Architecture and Urban Development 3(2), 67-74.

Naghsan Mohammadi, M. & Bagherinezad M. (2013). (Bazyabi Hoviyat Mahalehaye Ghadimi dar Tarh Behsazi va Nosazi Mantaghe Markazi Mashhad, Nemune Moredi: Mahale Noghan), International Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture & Urban Sustainable Development, Tabriz.

Orueta, F. D. & Fainstein, S. S. (2008). The New Mega-Projects: Genesis and Impacts, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 32(4), 759–767. DOI:10.1111/j.1468-2427.2008.00829.x

Priemus, H., Flyvbjerg, B. & Wee, B.V. (2008). Decision-making on Mega-Projects, Cost-Benefit Analysis, Planning and Innovation, Cheltenham, UK. Northampton, MA. : Edward Elgar.

Rafiee, R., Salman Mahiny, A., Khorasani, N., & Darvishsefat, A. A.(2009). Simulating Urban Growth-Mashhad, Cities, 26, 19–26. DOI:10.1016/j.cities.2008.11.005.

Rahnama, M. (2008). Impacts of Rehabilitation and Redevelopment Plans in Mashhad Downtown on Payin Khiyaban neighborhood (Asarate Ejraye Tarhhaye Behsazi va Nosazi Markaz Shahre Mashhad Bar Mahaleye Payin Khiyaban), Ghoghrafiya va Tosee Shahri (11),157-180.

Rahnama, M. & Abbaszade, G. (2006). Comparison Study on the Assessment of Sprawl/Density of Metropolitans: Mashhad and Sydney (Motaleye Entebaghi Sanjesh Daraje Parakanesh/ Feshordegi Dar Kalanshahrhaye Sydney va Mashhad), Ghoghrafiya va Tosee Nahiyei (6),101-128.

Samen Municipality (2015). Retrieved September 10, 2015, from  https://samen.mashhad.ir/.

Sarkheyli, E., Pourjafar, M. & Rafieian, M. (2015). Assessing the Convergence Effects of Religious and Economic forces on the Contemporary Changes of Form and Shape of Samen Region in Mashhad, Motaleat Shahri (12), 87-101.

Scerri, A. & James, P. (2010). Accounting for Sustainability: Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Research in Developing Indicators of Sustainability, International Journal of Social Research Methodology 13 (1), 41-53. DOI: 10.1080/13645570902864145.

Tash (2015). Retrieved April 1, 2015, from http://www.tash.co.ir/

Ziyaiyan, P., Soleymani Moghadam, H. & Barzegar, S. (2011). Determination of the Best Direction for Mashhad Physcial Expansion Using Multiple Factor Analysis (Taiene Jahate Behine Baraye Tosee Mashhad Ba Estefade Az Tahlil Chand Ameli), Faslname Elmi Pazuheshi Ghoghrafiya (30),75-94.